Differences between mechanical or quartz watches

Advices le 23 January 2013 par Traz "the doc"

You can choose a watch according to various features: style, special functions, but you can’t deny the movement remains a key one to consider for any watch amateur. Two main movement types exists: mchanical and quartz. Here are few explanations about those:

Mechanical Watches:

movado automatic

Watch: Movado Datron automatic

A mechanical watch movement is exclusively assured by mechanical items moving together (gearwheels, springs, prawls…). Up to the hands, the energy is provided by a spring untighening gradually and making the different gearwheels turning. Two types of mechanical watches can be found according to the way they wind up:
– The hand-wound watch has to be wound turning the crown by hand. It has to be made regularly.
– The automatic watch features a rotor turning as you keep your wrist moving. Then, the winding is automatically made as long as you wear the watch.
Hand-wound and automatic movements both presents advantages and drawbacks: the first is finer and the second cand avoid manually winding the watch.

Quartz Watches:

lip himalaya

Watch: Lip Himalaya

The quartz movement is quite a recent invention in the great World of watchmaking, as the first watch featuring a quartz movement is dated from 1969 (it was actually the Seiko 35SQ). They work with a piezoelectric movement, meaning that: as it is exposed to electric currents, the quartz crystal vibrates on a very high and regular frequency. So counting the number of vibrations will measure time.

As the quartz movement precision is exteme, from about few seconds a month (the best mechanical watches have a precision from about few seconds a day), quartz really was a major evolution at that time. Besides, few programming lines can easily allow adding many functions (chronograph, alarm, calendar, moon phases, tides schedule) when they can hardly be added to a mechanical movement. Finally, quartz movements are sturdier, having a better resistance to shocks and vibrations.

Hybrid watches:


Watch: Seiko SKA369P1 Kinetic

Here is a third category of movements, neither mechanical, nor electronic; quite a union between those two Worlds actually. Again, the Japanese Seiko initiated those “hybrid” watches through two inventions: the Kinetic and the Spring Drive. A Kinetic movement follows the same regulating system than a quartz, so here the energy does not comes from a battery, but from a accumulator recharged with a oscilliating mass. Then, the watch is as precise as a quartz and freed from any battery life.

As for the Spring Drive, it is very innovative, quite revolutionary. This movement is told to replace a classic mechanical regulating system (escapement and balance) with a electromagnetic-quartz regulation, all while keeping the whole mechanical transmission, from the retor to the hands, through the barrel.

Which to choose?

swatch-Black Laquered

Watch: Watch Black Lacquered

Choosing such or such a movement type depends on various parameters starting with the price. While you can buy quartz watches for few euros, a simple mechanical watch soon turns to be a real investment of several hundreds euros, even thousands for complex movements (chronograph, moon phase, alarm…). Then your choice could be influenced by a specific type of use; for example we would advice wearing quartz models for any activity implying shocks and vibrations (sports), when a finest model would give an elegant touch to a formal outfit. Finally, some like to know that a heart beats on their wrist. What about you, are you more mechanical or quartz?

par Traz "the doc"

Retrouvez les conseils de Traz "the doc" sur son site French Truckers

Tags: ,

Articles similaires

Voir la rubrique Watches